| Championnat de la Ville de Metz Appariements de la ronde 4 | |||||||
| Ech. | Pts | Blancs | Res. |
Noirs | Pts | ||
| 1 | [3] | HARTMANN Dominique | 1986 | 0-1 | ZIMMERMANN Denis | 1810 | [3] |
| 2 | [2,5] | KIEFER Eric | 1831 | 1-0 | BRICKLER Alain | 1860 | [2,5] |
| 3 | [2] | ALEXANDER Christian | 1867 | 1-0 | ZIMMER Marc | 1660 | [2] |
| 4 | [2] | SCHMIDT Alain | 1760 | 1-0 | ALIF Francis | 1808 | [2] |
| 5 | [2] | VILLIERE Christophe | 1499 | 1-0 | EZRATTI Andre | 1784 | [2] |
| 6 | [2] | PUCHER Daniel | 1767 | 1-0 | LECLAINCHE Wlady | 1720 | [2] |
| 7 | [2] | LUPFER Anny | 1662 | 0-1 | MERCIER Laurent | 1760 | [2] |
| 8 | [2] | HAUTCOEUR Damien | 1737 | 1-0 | LEBLANC Bernard | 1756 | [1,5] |
| 9 | [1] | GOETZ Lucien | 1520 | 1/2 | SORIGUE Augustin | 1874 | [1,5] |
| 10 | [1] | RAULIN Frederic | 1499 | F-1 | RAMIER Maxime | 1590 | [1] |
| 11 | [1] | WUSTMANN Pascal | 1360 | 0-1 | SCHNEIDER Marc | 1560 | [1] |
| 12 | [1] | RAMIER Julien | 1170 | 0-1 | DESCAMPS Nicolas | 1499 | [1] |
| 13 | [1] | PARACIEY David | 1499 | 0-1 | PIERRAT John | 1460 | [1] |
| 14 | [0,5] | REBOURS Christian | 1570 | 0-1 | CHRISTIANY Marc | 1440 | [1] |
| 15 | [0] | GHISU David | 1499 | 0-1 | PEULTIER Michel | 1470 | [0] |